MTA’s buses continue to idle over the 1-minute limit set in the school zone on Lincoln Road. Despite our post and the ongoing attention this page is getting (eight months later, it continues to be one of the most visited pages on this blog), MTA buses are back at it in full force. Our video, taken by camera phone at 6:50 AM the morning after Thanksgiving, demonstrates the kind of congestion and pollution that occurs on a daily basis, regardless of the warm weather, supposed holiday schedule, supervisor presence, or posted “NO IDLING” Department of Transportation sign (with accompanied threat of $2,000 fine).
We had a brief respite over the summer when it seemed as though our complaints were heard. Now, we are very disappointed that MTA continues to act like an irresponsible neighbor. The link between air pollution and respiratory diseases, cancer and decreased IQ levels has been established in numerous studies–as has the fact that young children are particularly susceptible. And yet, MTA buses continue to idle all day, every day, for sometimes up to 15 minutes at a time.
It is the rare exception that we see an MTA bus arrive, park, and have its engine shut off. We continue to see buses idling, doors wide open, with the bus driver out on the street smoking a cigarette or chatting with the scheduling supervisor. All seem oblivious to the ongoing noise, air and dust pollution their buses bring to our neighborhood every day. In one particularly egregious case, we saw a bus driver, after idling her particularly loud bus for over 5 minutes, open her driver’s window to drop a plastic wrapper on the street. Meanwhile, trash cans are available right outside, up and down Lincoln Road.
Idling buses, besides being linked to serious illnesses and environmental pollution, waste money. Earlier this year, the MTA announced that it was in such dire financial straits that it considered cutting its subsidy of student cards. It has since slashed bus routes, subway lines and prepared to lay off workers. And yet, every day, in front of our neighborhood preschool, buses waste fuel and money.
We are sending a letter to the MTA to encourage it to follow these practical recommendations:
- Respect the law and obey the 1-minute idling limit in this school zone;
- Install kill switches in their buses to ensure that buses cannot idle when parked;
- Reduce neighborhood noise pollution by scheduling quieter hybrid buses for late night/early morning runs; and
- Reduce traffic congestion by having buses run on large, high traffic streets, instead of narrow, high-density residential ones.
By following these straightforward, manageable recommendations, the MTA can be a better neighbor not just to our block, but to the environment in general.
Below is a snapshot of recent bus idle times, one noisy November day. We casually counted 12 buses idling throughout the day. At one point, 3 buses were idling simultaneously, creating an incredibly loud living environment, and adding significantly to traffic congestion.
For November 3, 2010
Bus no. |
Route |
Time in |
Time out |
Elapsed |
836 |
B16 |
12:26 PM |
12:32 PM |
6 MINS |
908 |
B16 |
1:10 PM |
1:15 PM |
5 MINS |
4555 |
B43 |
4:42 PM |
4:50 PM |
8 MINS |
4516 |
B43 |
4:45 PM |
4:50 PM |
5 MINS |
928 |
B16 |
5:05 PM |
5:13 PM |
8 MINS |
9509 |
B43 |
5:13 PM |
5:17 PM |
4 MINS |
4523 |
B43 |
5:37 PM |
5:45 PM |
8 MINS |
4531 |
B43 |
5:54 PM |
6:01 PM |
7 MINS |
932 |
B16 |
5:54 PM |
6:00 PM |
6 MINS |
4568 |
B43 |
5:54 PM |
6:00 PM |
6 MINS |
9486 |
B43 |
6:35 PM |
6:39 PM |
4 MINS |
950 |
B43 |
8:04 PM |
8:10 PM |
6 MINS |
Read Full Post »